New York’s Department of Financial Services (NYDFS) has put forth a formal regulatory proposal aimed at harmonizing its existing stablecoin framework with the federal GENIUS Act, which was enacted last year. This new rule package, titled “Authorized Payment Stablecoin Issuers,” preserves the foundational requirements established in the department’s 2022 guidance. These include mandates for one-to-one backing with U.S. dollars, adherence to redemption standards, the use of permissible reserve assets, and the necessity of independent audits.
Key Takeaways
- New York’s Department of Financial Services has formalized its stablecoin regulations, aligning them with the federal GENIUS Act.
- The proposed rule introduces concentration limits for reserves held with single custodians.
- Stricter risk management programs and dual certification for reserve reporting are now required.
- Issuers with over $25 billion in outstanding stablecoins must hold a minimum percentage in insured deposits.
- Specific redemption timelines and clear procedures for winding down operations in case of reserve deficiencies are outlined.
A notable addition to the proposed rule involves the diversification of reserve assets across multiple custodians, incorporating explicit maximum concentration limits for any single custodial relationship. This requirement was not present in the original 2022 guidance. Furthermore, stablecoin issuers will be mandated to implement comprehensive risk management programs. These programs are expected to cover internal controls, information security, internal audit systems, asset growth monitoring, earnings analysis, insider and affiliate transactions, and oversight of third-party service providers.
The rule also introduces a layered certification process for reserve reporting. Each month, the Chief Executive Officer and Chief Financial Officer of a licensed issuer must certify the accuracy of the reserve composition report. Annually, a registered public accounting firm must attest to the effectiveness of internal controls pertinent to reserve compliance. An additional requirement is placed on issuers with an outstanding stablecoin value of $25 billion or more. These entities will be compelled to maintain at least 0.5% of their reserves, capped at $500 million, in insured deposits with an insured depository institution.
Regarding redemption processes, the proposal sets a maximum timeframe of two business days for fulfilling redemption requests from holders. Only the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency (OCC), the Federal Reserve, or the NYDFS Superintendent may authorize discretionary extensions to this timeline. In instances where an issuer fails to meet its minimum reserve requirement for 15 consecutive business days, the rule stipulates an immediate initiation of a wind-down process. This would involve liquidating reserves and redeeming all outstanding coins without any charge to customers.
The list of prohibited activities has also been expanded. The rehypothecation of reserve assets is strictly forbidden, with very narrow exceptions requiring superintendent approval. Additionally, practices such as tying arrangements, misleading marketing, misrepresenting insured status, and paying interest on stablecoins are prohibited, mirroring the stipulations within the GENIUS Act and the OCC’s implementing framework.
This regulatory proposal is strategically designed to satisfy the Treasury Department’s “substantially similar” certification standard. This standard is critical for determining whether a state’s regulatory framework can retain oversight of stablecoin issuers with outstanding issuance values below $10 billion, thereby preventing the automatic transfer of oversight to federal regulators.
A brief 10-day pre-proposal comment period commenced on June 9, preceding a formal 60-day comment period that will follow the rule’s publication in the State Register. Existing stablecoin licensees operating under New York’s current regime have until the conclusion of the comment period to submit their feedback before the rule is finalized. The rule is slated to take effect concurrently with the operational date of the GENIUS Act, providing licensed issuers with a one-year compliance period. The 2022 guidance will remain in effect until this transition is complete.
The OCC’s February proposal concerning the GENIUS Act’s implementation established the reserve and custody requirements that New York’s current proposal adopts. Concurrently, the FDIC proposed its own stablecoin rules in April, completing a coordinated federal effort that has now prompted the NYDFS’s regulatory action.
Potential Regulatory Precedent
New York’s proposed rule stands to set a significant precedent for state-level regulation of stablecoin issuers, particularly in its alignment with federal legislation and its introduction of enhanced prudential standards. By codifying and expanding upon its existing guidance, the NYDFS is demonstrating a proactive approach to stablecoin oversight that aims to meet federal standards while maintaining state-level control. The inclusion of reserve concentration limits and detailed risk management program requirements goes beyond the foundational elements of the 2022 guidance, reflecting evolving best practices and federal directives. This comprehensive approach, especially the dual certification and annual attestation mechanisms, could influence how other states develop or refine their own stablecoin regulations. Furthermore, by explicitly designing the rule to achieve the Treasury’s “substantially similar” threshold, New York is reinforcing the viability of a dual regulatory system, where states can effectively oversee certain classes of issuers, thereby reducing the burden on federal agencies and allowing for potentially more tailored supervision.
Learn more at : www.theblock.co